Deogratias, A Tale of Rwanda (graphic novel) by J.P. Stassen
An important tale to be told - unfortunately this one fails to tell it well enough
Published by First Second in 2006.
Deogratias is the name of a young man from Rwanda. The story dances back and forth between pre- and post-1994 massacre Rwanda. Pre-massacre Deogratias is a likeable young man. Post-massacre Deogratias is insane. As one reads this graphic novel one finds out what drove him insane - in a climax that is not all that surprising or shocking (just sad), especially if one knows any of the detail of the Rwanda massacre.
Great
works take the story of one person or group of people in a tragic
situation and somehow make their story universal. For example, the Civil
War movie Glory is the story of the first all-Black Federal regiment
in the Civil War - it is also the story of every soldier - black or
white, Union or Confederate. In Saving Private Ryan, the Tom Hanks
character epitomizes the average man stuck in a terrible situation doing
the best he can and dying in the process.
Deogratias fails to do this. It is too personal. The story is too small. Not to say it isn't important, but rather to say that it fails to become a universal story of the Rwanda tragedy.
My copy of the book has an introduction from Alexis Seigel, the translator. He does an exceptional job of explaining the Rwanda tragedy and its aftermath. I would give his introduction 5 stars.
However, the grade has to go to the graphic novel, not its introduction. So, I give this graphic novel 3 stars out of 5.
This graphic novel can be found on Amazon.com here: Deogratias: A Tale of Rwanda.
Reviewed on December 11, 2006.
This book was listed on a "banned book" list in Florida. Ugh.
Published by First Second in 2006.
Deogratias is the name of a young man from Rwanda. The story dances back and forth between pre- and post-1994 massacre Rwanda. Pre-massacre Deogratias is a likeable young man. Post-massacre Deogratias is insane. As one reads this graphic novel one finds out what drove him insane - in a climax that is not all that surprising or shocking (just sad), especially if one knows any of the detail of the Rwanda massacre.
 |
| An image from the graphic novel |
Deogratias fails to do this. It is too personal. The story is too small. Not to say it isn't important, but rather to say that it fails to become a universal story of the Rwanda tragedy.
My copy of the book has an introduction from Alexis Seigel, the translator. He does an exceptional job of explaining the Rwanda tragedy and its aftermath. I would give his introduction 5 stars.
However, the grade has to go to the graphic novel, not its introduction. So, I give this graphic novel 3 stars out of 5.
This graphic novel can be found on Amazon.com here: Deogratias: A Tale of Rwanda.
Reviewed on December 11, 2006.
This book was listed on a "banned book" list in Florida. Ugh.
And it was put on a book ban list in Tennessee. The article has a searchable database because the list has more than 1,100 unique titles.
Comments
Post a Comment